Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 11th September 2023 Written Episode, Written Update on TellyUpdates.com
The Episode starts with Abhir and Muskaan going home. Abhir sees Manjiri. He calls out Dida. Muskaan ends the call. Abhir says stop the car, Dida is on the road, she isn’t well. She says fine. She sees Kairav and Pallavi going. Abhir says we have to go to Dida. Driver asks shall we go back. Muskaan says follow that car. She says don’t call anyone Dida, she isn’t Manjiri. Abhir says she is Dida. He prays to Shiv ji. Manjiri gets dizzy. Abhi and Akshu come there. Abhi shouts Maa and runs to hold her. They take Manjiri in the car. Abhir says Dida is alone, anything can happen to her. Muskaan says she would be resting at home, where did Kairav’s car go. At home, Aarohi treats Manjiri. Anand says physical wounds will heal, but it will take much time to deal with mental trauma. Mahima says Abhi, you have to take care of her. Abhi thinks of Manjiri. He goes. She says he isn’t understanding. Akshu stops Abhi and says Maa needs you. He doesn’t listen. She says his guilt is increasing. Manish asks didn’t she tell you anything. Suwarna says no, she isn’t answering. Kairav says courts are closed today. Surekha says her laptop is here, she didn’t go to meet the client. Muskaan says take medicines, she will come. Manish says no. Akshu comes home. Everyone asks where did you go. Manish says you didn’t answer the phone. Akshu tells everything.
Muskaan thinks Abhir was telling the truth. Abhir says I saw Dida on the road, I told Muskaan, Dida doesn’t look well, we should stop the car. Manish asks what is he saying. Dadi scolds Muskaan. Manish asks Abhir to go to room and play. Abhir says sorry to Muskaan and goes. Manish asks what happened, did you think she can’t be Manjiri. Muskaan says I really felt Abhir just thought so, I had to reach office. Akshu asks was reaching office imp than someone, its because of hatred for Abhi and his family. Muskaan says no, this happened because of love. Akshu asks what do you mean. Muskaan holds Kairav’s hand and takes him. She tells everything about Kairav and Pallavi. Surekha says they have an affair. Manish asks Surekha to stop it. Muskaan says I saw my husband roaming outside with his manager. Kairav says we can talk. She argues.
Kairav says its Muskaan and my matter, I don’t want anyone to come between it. Manish says Kairav. Kairav says sorry, and takes Muskaan with him. Akshu boils the milk. She puts off the stove. She gets Neela’s call. She says I had sent someone to Abhi for the surgery, but he said he can’t do it. Akshu says Aarohi will arrange the best doctor. Neela says they went there on my saying, ask Abhi to do the operation. Akshu says fine, he will do it. Neela asks how is Abhir, how is everyone. Akshu says he is fine, he misses you a lot. Neela asks how are Muskaan and Kairav. Akshu says everything is fine, take care. Neela says Muskaan is immature, she isn’t bad-hearted, if she does wrong, then pull her ears, take care of everyone and yourself. Akshu says yes, take care.
Kairav comes. Akshu gives him a cup of coffee. She explains him about Muskaan. She says you have to handle Muskaan with care, she is insecure because she loves you a lot. He says love isn’t good when it makes you lose common sense, she must understand, if any big problem comes, then how will I explain her, there is nothing between Pallavi and me, we just work together. Akshu says I think I have a solution.
At Birla hospital, Akshu asks the girl not to worry. The girl says I trust Abhi, now someone else is doing my surgery. The man says Neela has sent us here, now Abhi isn’t available. Akshu asks Aarohi will the other doctor do it. Aarohi says yes, but Abhi is the best. Abhi asks Dr. Bindra to talk to the patient before the surgery. Dr. Bindra says but you should do it. Abhi says best of luck. Akshu stops Abhi and says you can’t get go your profession, its imp for you, if you don’t want to live as a doctor, then remove this Dr from your nameplate. He says no. She breaks it. She says give your degree, its useless and soon it will have value as junk, if you don’t want to save lives, then you don’t need to become a part of this noble profession, you are a problem, you are becoming selfish. He says I don’t trust myself, I m doing it for that girl’s good. She says you are lying, you would have saved Manjiri if you didn’t get stuck, his reactions and decisions get extreme, you regret it later, you need that girl more than she needs you, you will regret a lot, please come out of this guilt, there is still time. He thinks. She goes.
Precap:
Akshu says I broke the nameplate. Abhi says you saved it, I think I m ready to meet Maa. Manjiri says I m fine. Abhi says you do aarti with me and face your fear. Akshu makes Abhi wear a cap.
Update Credit to: Amena
123 Comments
Congratulations Jay Soni on your awards.
What can I say, Kairav is as dumb as his sister Akshara. Kairav is glued to his manager like gum. What’s the use of employing a manager if you end up doing most of the work? Better he hires a personal assistant.
And this Akshara, she shouldn’t have left BH 7yrs ago if she is to end up there again.
@IrCy, “As I expected, now we will be shown adults and mature heroes who have made a lot of mistakes, have become more understanding, have become more tolerant of each other, more cautious and restrained.” Really???? Was Akshara’s screaming today, tolerant and cautious and restraint?😂 Manyu is fine now. He will soon start screaming too. Manyu needs a slap and a scold. Akshara needs to mind her business and her son.
Certainly! Seriously! They do everything with love! Darlings scold, only amuse themselves!
They will fall in love with each other more and more in each episode, until the creators remember Arohi’s engagement, then let Akshara climb the tree! 😀 😀 😀
@IrCy How can they fall in love more and more when they are not in love in the first place?
It gives the impression that you are not watching the episodes, but only reading the updates! :’-D
You consider friendship with Nav to be love, Abhimanyu’s care is considered to be a desire to control, and the love of the main characters of this show, who already have a child together, has not yet begun for you!
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, love is seen by those who know what it is. This is not a marriage, this is not a stamp in the passport, this is not respect and care, but this is exactly what is happening now between the main characters and what is being shown to us now! And that’s great!
Very beautifully done, thanks to the creators!
@IrCy
I cannot comment if I have not watched the epi. I cannot do that. I have seen how Akshara couldn’t hold it anymore and looked Manyu in disdain as he tells him you are selfish for turning a child away just because you are guilty. She was so fed up with his big baby in an adult body. She literally came cool and begging but then she snapped and gave up trying to baby him anymore. I am sure what made her snap at him is the fact that, she has been through worse than him but at the time, she put her big girly panties on and started making decisions of her life and that of her unborn son, whereas, this man child can’t handle the fact that his mom is alive and calling out for him. But of course you will call this love.
*I have seen how Akshara couldn’t hold it anymore and looked at Manyu in disdain as she tells him, “you are selfish for turning a child away just because you are guilty”. She was so fed up with his big baby in an adult body attitude. She first came to Manyu in a cool way and begging, but then she snapped and gave up trying to baby him anymore.
@Mark, Abhimanyu is a controlling abuser who loves no one but his mother and only covets Akshara, dreaming of how to use her and throw her away like garbage?
Akshara was offended, she was treated poorly, she decided to take revenge on everyone and not tell about her son to the one who dreamed of a son more than anything in the world. Because of her great love for her family and her unwillingness to hurt them, she hides her son from them too. Am I describing everything correctly?
Through circumstances beyond her control, she finds herself again next to the Gorillas and the most cruel man in the world, whom she never loved! She has her own house in Kasauli, Nila Maa, a hotel at home, a well-established jam-making business, and now also a diploma as a practicing lawyer in her pocket, what prevents her from living in her little cozy world and leaving these internecine wars for the sake of peace in everything the world?
This is just complete depression all around, I can’t imagine how you can watch and comment on this garbage, I sincerely feel sorry for you! I hope you didn’t suffer too much while watching!
I see two lovers who were united by God and fate, who have always been halves of one whole, who quarrel, swear, fight, part, but never stop loving each other for a moment. Akshara’s first words after the birth of her child were – Abi! Abhimanyu’s first words when he woke up after a serious accident were – Akshu…
I watch a wonderful show, with beautiful characters, enjoy life, and I wish the same for you!
@IrCy
Akshara was not offended for being treated poorly. She did not resort to revenge. You didn’t get that correctly. The correct narrative would be, Akshara was traumatized after being treated poorly. Regardless of that, she told the father of her son about his child but he didn’t want anything to do with his son(this is how traumatized people are vulnerable). When her trauma subsided, she realized this is the life she wanted for herself. Away from Udaipur city and her past. She never wanted to go back. She started a new life. But her past never wanted to stay away. Her past caused problems after problems for herself and her love Nav and her son. Now that her love is gone, she is left with her son who needs family love and support. So she needs to work. She got an internship that is in Udaipur she is on it. So why is she not focusing on her life and son? This is what is making me watch. My own narrative. Not the one you pointed out.
NB: Akshara said she didn’t think about revenge when she was hiding Abhir from him. She said so herself. So where did you get the revenge word.
Also, keep dreaming that Akshara uttered Abhi when she gave birth to Abhir. Keep dreaming. Don’t stop.
Who is Akshara? Why does everyone try on this character for themselves?
Akshara is a bright, sensual person who was born a creative person, became an actress, a singer! She likes to dress up, make up (she had 98 lipsticks, imagine how many dresses and shoes there were!).
Do you think that she “she realized this is the life she wanted for herself. Away from Udaipur city and her past. She never wanted to go back” – since childhood she dreamed of living in a village and in dung? Maybe she liked this place because she hid there? Just like an ostrich? Or like small children who cover their faces with their hands and think that they cannot be seen?
She had problems, created even bigger problems for herself, and simply decided to run away from them rather than solve them.
She didn’t even want to talk about the baby, it was Nav who convinced her to call.
“Akshara said she didn’t think about revenge when she was hiding Abhir from him” – I think only the first part was true! She didn’t think! She passed out in her pain. That is why I wrote before that she was a sleeping beauty at that time.
If she thought, she would remember how Abhimanyu grew up without fatherly love, he did not have a normal relationship with his father, she would remember how Abhimanyu dreamed of becoming a father, how he took care of her and covered all the corners of the room with pillows, how he performed her every dream, even if she wanted snow. She forgot all this and remembered only her pain. Just like Abhimanyu himself that day. Similar! They both hurt each other that day!
It is difficult to understand the statement that Akshara never loved Abhimanya, when she herself, in a private conversation with Manish, concluded everything that happened – there was love and strength, only circumstances from the outside were against them.
@IrCy
Are you saying Akshara’s love for lipstick and dressing up is because she was with Manyu? Can’t she have her luxuries anywhere else than as Manyus wife????😂😂😂
Also, when did Akshara ever thought???? Even now she is not thinking. That’s my point. She will reunite with Manyu because she is incapable of thinking beyond the now and here. That’s who she is. Are you only realizing this now?😂
She told Manish the love was strong but couldn’t withstand the storm. Yes. What’s the guarantee that it will ever withstand anything, even wind the next time? Especially if it was pieced back with 3rd grade glue and built on poor foundation of Arus engagement???
“Are you saying Akshara’s love for lipstick and dressing up is because she was with Manyu?” – no, this is a character trait, I explain that with Abi she was herself – lively, cheerful. After she had a fight with Abi and broke each other’s hearts and she left for Udaipur, Akshara was not happy there, did not breathe deeply, was not herself, did not sing and did NOT love (you remember that she said – love is music)! She was just about to do it! Just after Abhimanyu woke her up!
@IrCy
Greatest joke of the day “..this is a character trait, I explain that with Abi she was herself – lively, cheerful. After she had a fight with Abi and broke each other’s hearts and she left for Udaipur, Akshara was not happy there, did not breathe deeply, was not herself, did not sing and did NOT love (you remember that she said – love is music)! She was just about to do it! Just after Abhimanyu woke her up”
A traumatized person can be her usual self? Well have you ever seen a traumatized person? A traumatized person filled with resentment, hatred, anger, will only heal once she faces her wounds and scars. Not before that. When Manyu appeared in her life after 7 yrs, Akshara said her peace and with Navs guidance, healed. And wasn’t she lively and cheerful before she met Manyu???? What are you saying yaar!
@Mark, “A traumatized person can be her usual self? Well have you ever seen a traumatized person? A traumatized person filled with resentment, hatred, anger, will only heal once she faces her wounds and scars. Not before that” – why would this be ? This is a very strong statement! All people experience differently and cope with their problems in different ways!
Don’t judge by yourself! If you didn’t get out, it doesn’t mean that no one will get out of this situation! In my life I have encountered worse situations, I have met many people and I can say with confidence – evil, selfish people, yes, perhaps in the way you say, but people who are patient, kind, filled with love, come out of trauma completely differently!
Lol akshu is focusing too much on abhimanyu now a days.. She forgot her husband so soon? Its good to move on but atleast take some time.. Abhimanyu loves akshara so is always focused on her.. But y akshu is focusing so much on him?? Thats y i say she actually never loved abhinav.. For her, nav was a great frnd and a companion.. But her heart always belonged to abhimanyu only
@Surabhi
Akshara loved Nav so much that she is looking for something to focus on so as her thoughts don’t wonder to Navs death. She is looking for a rebound and Manyu was a willing.
You sounding like Muskaan
@mark common even muskan must be having male coworkers.. Just coz kairav is busy in his work with pallavi muskan is blaming him for having EMA with her 😒 she is wrong
@Surabhi
It’s not about Muskaan having male coworkers. Its about this manager who seems to be inexperienced and unqualified that it raises questions. If she is unable to do most of the work, how did she get employed? How is she still employed?
@surabhi The characters will never have happiness muskaan just got married and she is not happy all soaps are the same always sadness
This akshara is getting on my nerves. And what’s wrong with this show, they all always make fun of every sensitive and serious issue. Manyu is not in a good frame of mind. Let him rest or something. He’s a surgeon dammit. One mistake and game over. Like someone said, just bc you can move on at the speed of a bullet train, you can’t except the same from everyone. First she forced abhir and now this. Give him atleast a week. She’s forcing things onto others like manyu used to do.
And what happened to your confidential case? Is it just to show her stupid heroism. Akshara’s dictionary lacks many words. ‘Boundaries’ is one of them. She neither sets one for herself nor she gives others some space. Always meddling in others lives.
@Gayu, I don’t think the writer knows which way to go. The previous writer gave Nav such a heartwarming send off (cause the previous writer actually knew how to write) and this one is just proving they are in the wrong profession, they can’t reach the levels the previous writer did so they are floundering. It feels like they don’t know which direction to go to in. Everything they try just makes their characters worse.
@Gayu
Exactly. Akshara is not giving space to anyone. She is always on their case and lives and everywhere else. She should have time for Abhir and herself. It’s like she has no time for herself and Abhir but has time for everyone else. This is what she becomes with Manyu. Manyu has a pot full of problems that it needs one to forever solve them and forget everything else. Manyu should just hire Akshara to solve all his problems and that of his family. Akshara should make a career out of Birlas problems.
@Jade, did they change the writers????
@Jade Agree
@Mark yep, they brought the cringebhira writer back hence the noted decay in content . Probably shoving her own fingers down her throat while she writes this crap
They really are trying to make Muskaan the vamp that brings Abhira together as @Siya used to say Abhira needs a villain to be together. They can’t use Aru anymore because she has shown several times her interest in Manyu was only due to his promise to be Ruhi’s papa but even Ruhi understands with Manyu talk is cheap… just hope one day she realizes herself that this grown ass adult man is using this little 6 year old baby as an emotional crutch and herself asks her matashree to take her away from such a useless, immature childish 40 something year old man. Once again they are showing this uselessManyu to be the only proper doctor in India…. It’s a shame everytime he gets an emotional boo boo he becomes unable to do his job. I have zero hopes for dumbshara, just go live in Birla house already, I am waiting for them to get mad at and scream at her again, maybe this time when Manyu is throwing around furniture he’ll hit her in the head and put her in a coma ( I’d rather she be in a coma than die, let Nav’s soul be in peace without her and Manyu be tormented with her 😈). @Mark is Manyu a psychologist too? He’s taking his mother near fire for exposure therapy it seems, her problem is more than being afraid of fire, she should have been in a straitjacket a few months back. I wonder why DKP think anyone wants to see ManyuJiri… psychojiri got off on such abhorrent behaviour with a stupid little apology and her murderer beta in jail for a few days…. Manyu never grieved Nav, and he still orbits around dumbshara using his son as an excuse, all his recent pitiful behavior is deliberate to draw dumbshara in because she has main character syndrome. RS this is getting boring, we want more Arohi and Ruhi cause Akshara and her Abhi’s are done, whatever you’re trying to do with Muskaan is also dumb, it feels like you killed Nav and that was the height of the story and now you don’t know what to do. Not killing Nav was a better option and you could have ended on a happy note with Abhir being carried by Manyu and Nav, no need for Akshara in the frame… reminds me of the time we were hoping for Akshara to end and Manyu, Nav and Abhir to be like 2 and a half men, Manyu could be like Charlie but celibate and Nav would have made a great Alan 🤔
@Jade
It seems Manyu got some new found psychologist skills now. Where were these skills when his son was dealing with shit?
I remember some people here said Abhir called Manyu, papa. They should keep dreaming. Especially if this Manyu cannot seem to get his head away from luring Akshara back to him. Manyu saw today that Akshara stopped babying him this is why he came out of his “I am the most guilty” act. Makers need to get their shit together. This shit is not worth 20min of anyone’s time.
@Mark abhir called manyu papa?? When? Or it’s just manyu stans saying so?
@Gayu
Manyu Stans were dreaming that some days back.
@Mark that was me I think, gossip articles came out saying Abhir would be stuck in the fire and call Manyu Papa. They need an actual plot they are testing the waters with this Muskaan and Kairav nonsense, just showing Nav was right about Kairav and Muskaan being a mismatch and what is Kairav constantly saying if he knew this or that he wouldn’t have married Muskaan, she left him and he kept chasing and now that he has her she’s a burden to him??? I’m disgusted with Kairav, he should have made time for Muskaan and taken her away from Udaipur for some time, maybe go to Mumbai with her and help her settle there but nooo… Nav told Muskaan to remember she came to Udaipur for work, I hope Muskaan herself remembers and goes to Mumbai for work. Akshara wants to stick her nose everywhere, she should have let Muskaan leave when she wanted to. Just because Akshara wants to be an abused DiL doesn’t mean Muskaan wants the same.
@Jade
“They need an actual plot they are testing the waters with this Muskaan and Kairav nonsense, just showing Nav was right about Kairav and Muskaan being a mismatch and what is Kairav constantly saying if he knew this or that he wouldn’t have married Muskaan, she left him and he kept chasing and now that he has her she’s a burden to him??? I’m disgusted with Kairav, he should have made time for Muskaan and taken her away from Udaipur for some time, maybe go to Mumbai with her and help her settle there but nooo”
Couldn’t agree more. Kai was the one chasing after Mus but now…….. Kairav could maintain boundaries with that manager of his, then Muskaan’s doubts couldn’t have escalated much. He should have taken Muskaan to Mumbai. I agree with you 💯
What was all that illogical screaming at Abhimanyu, Akshara? A person is defined by his values not by his education.You should have told him to honour his commitment, duty, promise to the girl who put her trust in you ( for surgery)…..oh oh forgot you never had those values😂😂. Never saw previous seasons were Kairav and Akshara parents equally dumb?Neither sister nor her brother knows personal and professional boundaries( kairav)
Exactly @Rr. Both brother and sister know nothing of boundaries. Akshara keep telling Manyu how being a doctor is his identity, bla bla bla. This is what she believes. Not Manyu. It’s like she is hypnotizing him with things that Manyu doesn’t recognize. This is how she sacrificed one year for “Manyus hand”. She believed that Manyu will be nothing without his hand and so she left for it. Even now, she is doing the same thing she did in one year leap. She never learns.
@Rr I always knew there was a reason Arohi didn’t really like Akshara… we’ve all been saying she should leave the Birla’s. But Aru doesn’t want to be on the Goenka house cause look at Kairav and Akshara they are the product of Manish and Suwarna, at least Aru had Sirat’s mom for a bit. Kartik and Naira weren’t such amazing human being either. All these kids (except Aru) may have OG Akshara’s blood but that’s all they have they can’t be like the OG couple that started it all.
@Rr as a viewer of previous seasons dumbshara and kairav’s parents were equally dumb. They love playing marriage/divorce game and running away from problems rather than having a proper communication with each other during crisis even for once. Only their grandparents (OG akshara and naitik) were the matured couple who were lovable, inspirational and communicated each other like matured adults during problems and easily resolved their issues within the four walls of their bedroom
@gayu true.. When problems come akshu herself runs away but now giving lectures to others.. Helping abhir was fine but it seems she was forcing abhir to forget abhinav nd enjoy with them.. Now she is forcing abhimanyu to come out of guilt.. Why didnt she force herself to face everyone nd go back to goenka house instead of staying with a stranger?
@Surabhi wahi toh, “Please come out of this time” she said. Only if things are that easy 🤦🏻♀️😅
*guilt
After abhinav’s death m reading updates only today and abhi and akshu’s friendship drama reminded me of a dialogue from movie “maine pyar kiya”…ek ladka aur ladki kabhi dost nhi ho skta,ye to sirf ek parda h parda do dhadhakte huye sharir ko santusht karne ka” something something…they both are fooling the whole world 🤣🤣
@Mahi
Exactly. Akshara doesn’t want to be alone so she is finding someone to attach herself to. Manyu as usual, he knows how to tune Akshara very well. He is using her support to keep her coming to him. You see today, when Akshara left Manyu, Manyu decided to use another strategy to keep Akshara with him. Otherwise, Akshara would have looked for company somewhere else.
@Mahi, Akshara has always been needy, I think that’s why I’ve never liked her even BEFORE Nav arrived, I preferred Arohi with Manyu but he turned to trash when he married her needy sister instead
@Surabhi
You compare 7yrs ago with now as if it’s the same. She stayed with a stranger because that stranger gave her peace and support.
Akshara completely deserves best DIL award.
On one hand she’s doing everything in her might to serve her abusive ex-mil and on the other hand she left neelamma who’s of the age of her mimi to die alone in another city
@mark thn y she is sticking to manyu? You are saying manyu is doing this purposely to be with akshara.. When was it shown that he is doing it purposely? Which episode you tell me? He is feeling guilty nd he didnt ask akshara to come nd help him.. She herself is coming to him.. When abhimanyu comes to akshara you say he has bad intentions nd even now you are blaming him when akshu is not giving him any space? You are the biggest blind hater of manyu here
@Surabhi
Akshara is sticking to Manyu to distract herself from thinking about Nav. She is not giving herself time alone but is busy with others matters why? Because she doesn’t want to face the fact that her husband who she loved so much is no more. This is normal.
You ask, ” When was it shown that he is doing it purposely”? Tell me why else, after Akshara gave up trying to convince Manyu about his guilt today, Manyu stopped feeling guilty? Unless he saw that Akshara is done with his “I am guilty” card so now, he is taking out another card to play Akshara. This is the vibes that Manyu is giving.
True Akshara never loved Nav. She just used him.
@mark @surabhi in yesterday episode Abhimanyu came to Akshara house at night on the bike. But@ mark they have not shown Akshara and Abhir thinking of Abhinav even once.She used to talk to his photo but thats stopped. I really think writers have changed and they are in a hurry to get to a reunion or a leap ,maybe both.
@Rr
Akshara is shown to be on others lives except her own which includes her son and her late husband. Makers are focusing on only one thing, to reunite these two. It’s becoming too bland for viewers. Makers are only showing other characters if they will contribute to reunion. Otherwise, they are sidelined or killed. If Muskaan and Kairav is shown now, it’s because they will bring about reunion e.t.c. their main focus is Manyu only. I won’t be surprised if trp drops more and more.
@ Also they both are crossing boundaries .For Abhimanyu one can justify as it’s shown he finds it difficult to forget his happy memories….but Akshara no justification why she goes running to Abhimanyu….And if Aarohi is still Abhimanyu fiancee she’s doing injustice to Aarohi…
@Rr
Akshara is running after Manyu
@Rr
Akshara is running after Manyu because she doesn’t want to feel lonely after Navs passing. She is looking for a distraction.
@priyanka how did he used him, did she tell him to be her for Abhir’s sake…… everything was Nav idea, so don’t blame Akshu
@priyanka is nav a dudh pita bacchha who was getting used for 5 years? Akshu didnt use him.. Both of them decided to coparent abhir.. But thn nav ji started loving her so out of courtesy she decided to start a fresh with him I guess
@mark o really? Doesnot she have a job to focus? Cant she focus on abhir? Why always abhimanyu only? Even sirat was better who took a long time before going back to kartik..
@Surabhi
Really. Manyu is offering himself to be Akshara’s distraction. Obviously Akshara will take the invite. Aksharas life means her son with her late husband. If she stays with Abhir, she will be forced to think about Nav. 6yrs is a long time. She never wanted Nav to be away from her line of vision. Now that he is gone, she needs to occupy her mind with something else that is not her life.
@priyanka how did she used him, did she tell him to be their for her for Abhir’s sake…… everything was Nav idea, so don’t blame Akshu.
The message was typing error
Sally, Surabhi and Mark…stop hating 1 dimensionally just abhi and abhinav ..they were both nice characters…honestly the real problem is akshara…and tbh abhinav was feeling sorry for her and got married to her…he Infact told her to call the father…but later he thought the father doesn’t wants the child and so out of sympathy …he got married to that needy and selfish girl…she didn’t do a favor on abhinav by making him Abhir’s dad ….it was he who did a favor on her by accepting her request and giving a name for that child…what she did back then with abhi was wrong…she was mad at him understandable…but she knew how much he cared about the babies…so she should have updated him on the child….she is a cold hearted selfish and needy woman with no spine….starting to understand why aarohi hated her
@Vandana
Exactly. Nav was doing Akshara a favor when she suggested they get married. It’s okay that Akshara didn’t persist to inform Manyu on Abhir after he showed no intention to hear her. Manyu did that to himself. But what Akshara and Manyu are doing now is bonkers. Manyu is using Akshara and Akshara is using Manyu too without a care of how it will affect Abhir. Her meddling Birlas business will disturb Abhirs life if she is not careful to set boundaries.
@Vandana
She legit tried to update him about the baby. He was the one who refused to listen to anything. If he cared sooo much about the babies why didn’t he care to listen even at the mention of the child? “I don’t want to listen anything about akshara and her baby” he said. Her baby? Really?
“She was mad at him understandable” she has every right to be mad at him.
The three of them are to be blamed here. Yes, even nav should have minded his own business. He shouldn’t have helped this ungrateful duffer.
But more blame goes to our manyu boy 🤷🏻♀️
@Mark and Gayu ….see he cut her call bcoz he was angry with her and she was partially responsible for Neil’s death like Abhi is partially responsible for abhinav’s death…actually she is partially responsible for abhinav’s death as well….I am not saying the way he treated her was right… I am not saying she should have gone back to him…but seeing what is happening now I would have prefered her being doormat at BH…. but he was the father and he was in the thought the babies died he didn’t want to listen to akshara at that time..and this akshara also knew his anger was on her…not like he didnt want to know about his child…she just decided to avenge her ego… she should have gone to the GH and told them to inform him about the baby and stayed at Goenka house…not gone to live with a stranger and asked him to marry her….I do love Abhinav but all what Akshara did and is doing is problematic
@Vandana my problem with Manyu is how long he’s going to be a sucker? Man doesn’t have any sense of self worth. He went to ask Akshara to leave her kid and husband for him then asked Nav to give his wife to him, in 6 years this man couldn’t build a bridge and get over his own BS. To top all that off he uses Ruhi as his emotional crutch, a grown ass man using a child. Time and time again he wants to be a pathetic baby crying on the floor with a bottle for all to see. If I knew someone like this in my life I’d put a pacifier in their mouth while they are laying on the floor now everyone can imagine Manyu with his pitiful crying face and a dummy 🤭 no one has as many self created problems as Abhimanyu Birla. He’s a god damned snowflake.
@ Jade I second your opinion…both MLs just go out of the way to invite problems….and I agree with u what he is doing with ruhi and Aarohi is very wrong…and what Akshara is doing with them also is wrong…she knows what all her sister has been through and is not maintaining a safe distance from her fiancee…but I think it is high time Aarohi takes a stand and leaves with her child to another city and starts over…not go to GH …goenka’s can only keep saying akshara is mahaan even when she is destroying aarohi’s life… they are not even bothered about what happened to there engagement…Aarohi should leave bcoz she is self sufficient and needs none of them to take care of her child.
but one thing is that he always loved akshara and was not able to move on from akshara…his love for her atleast was true…that way atleast he is better than her and deserves better.!
@Vandana, so refreshing to read someone isn’t viewinh from a one-dimensional stand. Best comment of the day.
I agree Akshara in many instances is the one at fault. From the moment she left Birla House we have watched the impact of decisions on the other characters. I still can’t get over Akshara choosing Arohi’s wedding day to admit her love for the groom, Abhimanyu.
But now watching to see what Akshara has learnt over the years and Abhimanyu too.
These are all beautiful composed characters and like life itself making all manner of well meaning mistakes, but getting things right too. But yeah, too sophisticated for a one-dimensional assessment.
@Rai
“I still can’t get over Akshara choosing Arohi’s wedding day to admit her love for the groom, Abhimanyu”🤔🤔🤔🤔 is this not one dimensional assessment. Wow.
@Mark, no, I was one-dimensional in the way I saw Akshara to that point: nice, sweet, self sacrificing, overlooked, ignored. But then suddenly without the blink of an eye she humiliates her sister in one of the most cruellest ways, in front of everyone. That introduced a steely determination to her character. I don’t believe she does anything out of innocence, there is a calculatedness in her. One-dimensional would be to see her as a victim to someone’s villainy.
@Sally
What exactly is nav’s idea? 🙄
It was akshara who asked him to be abhir’s father. She even married him. He was just helping her. A lonely girl who’s pregnant and was abandoned by her husband. So someone helps you and you go on to ask them more favours and in the end blame them for helping you in the first place?
After all this she’s running back to manyu and you say there’s nothing to blame her?
@Gayu
Akshara also was the one that told Nav to marry her on top of being Abhirs papa.
And now what that devi is doing on another dimension….it’s super desperate…like I don’t have him…so I will just adjust with the next best thing not giving a f**k about anyone else…for instance muskaan is legit depressed after abhinav death and neelamma is all alone…and she just doesn’t care…all she cares suddenly about is just abhi and his mom😂😂
Exactly @Vandana. She is ready to settle for just anyone if it means she is not lonely.
@Vandana I can’t stand her, I never could I’ve always felt Arohi deserved to be the lead. They could have set her up as the central character whose sister stole her fiancé and shown Neil marrying her to compensate for his brother. NeiRohi would be happy and Manyu would be the always miserable husband of Akshara
@ Mark it is high time to accept she didn’t love abhinav truly…she has always liked poking her nose everywhere…it has nothing to do with coping up with abhinav death
@vandana
Then what was all that she was doing???? Drama??? Then she must be the most dramatic being on earth.
honestly if it was love she wouldn’t be running behind abhi and his mom now and not give a shit about people whom abhinav considered as family
but saying that I shall also state that she never truly loved abhi as well bcoz then she wouldn’t have moved on soo easily and married the next man she finds and fall in love with him as well….honestly i think she just likes ppl who at that moment are ready to consider her mahaan xD… she is an insult for og Akshara….I remember when Naitik’s sister fell in love everyone in the house blamed her and didn’t talk to her when she had no mistake….even Naitik blamed her…she had self respect and left the house but went to parent’s house not run away the very instance and get married to the next man
Akshara said “Abhi” when she was delivering Abhir.😂😂😂😂😂😂 then she must have said that a lot in those 6yrs.
@Mark, It’s very easy to check, it’s not fantasy, just open Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 9th January 2023 (episode 394) and watch the episode (don’t read the updates).
Good luck.
There are atleast 40 to 50 members in the team making this show like writers, camera department,helpers,actors,editor,etc.not even one of them were able to see that their resources like time,money and energy is only injecting nibbish behaviour into this toxic society? They make fun of toxic relationships making Abhira as endgame.There might be some genuine fans of Abhira who are expecting some quality storyline for the leads with proper redemption.Even that is tossed to just satisfy some finger licking cringe fans? What a shame!! No wonder show is taking a leap in November.
@Nani
As long as people receive their monthly cheque, other things are unimportant. Harsh reality in this harsh world.
@vandana go and see the episode when she asks him to be Abhirs father…See Nav s expression it’s as if he got the world !! He has repeatedly said that with Akshara and Abhir he got a family ( which all three treasured) The last 7 months were the best part of yrkkh.as in Akshnav they showed loyality,devotion and invisible binding of a family,for six years!! Love as physical love was immaterial but they were each other’s support.
That’s why Akshara present interference in the Birla family is so irritating.
ur right they made a nice family together…but how many of us would go out of the way to do something for someone else’s child…I understand Abhinav was poor but he could have found any girl ….but Akshara’s case even if she found another man it would have been impossible to find a father for her child… so she is lucky that Abhinav agreed….and she is lucky that he was a good man who saw her child as his own child…for me personally 70% of the mistakes are Akshara’s and 35% of the mistakes were abhimanyu’s….Abhinav had no mistake on his side…and I could somehow forgive akshara for her earlier mistakes bcoz the person with whom she moved on was a gem…and every way right for her…but once he died she runnning back to abhi is very annoying…It makes me feel like she just needs a man in her life no matter who…tbh her problems aren’t even serious …the only person who suffered a lot in this Abhira mess is Aarohi and she as an inspiring female and worthy being a lead not Akshara
@Vandana exactly only aarohi and abhinav deserved to be the leads toxicshara and toxicmanyu’s faces are unbearable.
@Nani 💯
When they introduced abhinav’s charecter I felt so happy that finally someone’s trying to show something progressive. They ruled out every possibility where people thought abhinav is just like every other cameo where he’ll turn negative/gray/grow jealous. There were rumours that he’ll just go away from ak and abhir when manjri asked him to leave them thinking that she’s right. But no ‘abhinav’ is unique, he’s not like all other cliche cameos. He stood out from the crowd. The episode where manyu asked nav to give ak back to him I thought, like a typical ‘accha aadmi’ he’ll obey to manyu. (many stans bashed him saying that he’s not a good man bc he didn’t obey to abhi, yes for them he’s bad bc he didn’t give away his wife to someone else🤡). But the way nav replied back to manyu 💥 nothing could make my love lessen for him after that episode. The epi where they took kalash for abhirohi’s pooja, there was a dialogue by him.. “Akshara, after what has happened, where people usually bring kalesh(quarrels), you brought kalash, KEEP YOUR HEAD HIGH. That was it. That’s the moment it was proved that he’s the hero of the show. That is a MAN right there. That’s how a partner should be. Nav is a breath of fresh air among all the toxic shows. Now I really didn’t expect this much downgrading after his death. ALL THE SIX MONTHS OF PROGRESSION WENT IN VAIN.
@Vandana, yes, Abhi loves Akshu more, that is why we are puzzled why the Abhira fans want Abhira to be the endgame? Abhi deserves better, so does Akshu she should not go back to Abhi after all the nonsense she got from him, isn’t it?
I just don’t understand when u guys comparing Aru to Akshu, and then said Aru should be the lead not Akshu, and yet this serial ML n FL are Abhi n Akshu no matter what right? So if Aru shuld be lead not Akshu, then just exchange the name of character, right? So tell me u guys are comparing the actresses or the characters or the names?🤔🤔🤔
@Tsk please watch all the episodes starting from gen 3 and upto today’s ep you will clearly then know why i said arohi deserved to be the lead. Her character developed from a jealous money hungry sister to an understanding, caring sister who’s also more career oriented. Whereas dumbshara learnt nothing and remained dumb. If dumbshara was a sensible and a better character me and anyone else who prefers arohi as lead would have preffered her.
@A, But the show is not over yet, so everything can change again!
If they brought Akshara and Abhimanyu back to where they started, then maybe Arohi will return. The engagement hasn’t been canceled yet, what if it gets canceled again on the wedding day? Maybe now Akshara will hang from a tree and force Abhimanyu to confess his love to her)). After all, for some reason they made him weak again 😀
@IrCy you’re right about this serial not being over. You know? I was a school kid when this show started and now im in my adulthood and this show is still going😂😂😂😂. Btw now that you mention it I really hope they don’t take another 360 negative U turn in arohi’s character once again when toxicmanyu breaks off engagement with her. That scene of hanging on a tree during abhira confession still makes me laugh😂😂i hope they don’t make akshara hang on that same tree again as you said. Because if that tree can talk, it will question why the humans are hanging on it😂😂😂. I hope they work on her and abhimanyu’s character
@A, I started watching only at the beginning of this season, but I read the series with Sirat in the Update in order to better understand the backstory.
I like this kind of long-running TV series, for aunts like me 🙂
@IrCy oh I see thats nice to know😄 thank you
@Tsk we are comparing characters arohi had a greater depth of character than this dumbshara. I never liked pranali in this role across from Harshad because it looked like 13 year old running behind her teacher.
it was an artistic move by the writers! When you are planning a series that will last for decades, it is logical that the actress will play a very young one, it will be in a sense a hyperbole, but well played, especially for the contrast later, with an adult personality.
This is not depth, these are just different characters, material and creative!
@Tsk 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 true!
@ Bu😂😂😂😂😂😂its you again. Pls see for yourself all episodes from very beginning of gen 3 and catch upto this day’s episode. See the progression of character arc of arohi and dumbshara. Then you will know why arohi deserved the lead role and not dumbshara. This is i think the first show where i hate the dumb leads. They should have made dumbshara and toxicmanyu as better human beings if they wants audience to like the dumb leads so much but no they prefer unrealistic whitewashing and ruining other couples just to reunite the mopheads. See how they are ruining kairav muskan to glorify their cringebhira
So Miss Free-Spirit, Runner, Akshara has learnt the art of facing-it-and-fighting-for-life, and is now using her new outlook to help Mr Deeply Tortured Abhimanyu to apply some of his wisdom that brought her from the pit of despair at Abhinav’s loss to embrace life anew.
He expresses his gratitude to her. And now these failures at their youthful marriage move on a little more than friends and a little less than significant others. For now?
@Rai
I kept asking myself why youthful marriage or young love when Manyu is like 40 yrs old and more now.
@Mark, ‘And now these failures at their youthful marriage…’ Youthful, as in the marriage was still in its formative years.
When they married Akshara would be 27/28, Abhimanyu about 31/32. After three years of marriage, before their mid-thirties, they divorce and now six years on Akshara is around 32/33 and Abhimanyu about 37/38.
Calculation based Arohi being 2 to 2.5 years older than Akshara. When we first meet the characters Arohi has just finished her med. degree, a five year course, making her 24/25 and Abhimanyu is a few years ahead of her in a medical career, as he is developing a good reputation as a cardiologist.
Though age in Indian serial is peculiar. Would a Mimi really be enjoying conversations with her great-great grandkids!
No logic, defy logic, nonsense serial YRKKH is about, that’s it! Why leap, when this generation already make no sense? What to expect after leap?
@Gayu
Totally agree with you.I was neutral in the beginning,then like you said he was a fresh air in this toxic drama.The scene which you mentioned is awesome,it shows how much they both respected each other and won’t tolerate others shit into their relationship.Even I thought he will turn into jealous or negative seeing the articles few toxic abhira fans write,spreading fake molestation charges 😡,threatening actor’s family,what not.They made joke of every sensitive issue they can,just be because they get to see some more finger licking romance???🙄🙄. It is pathetic when people can’t differentiate between actor and character, attacking actors.But Jay handled really well by blocking and ignoring that shit heads👏👏👏.
Most of the couples in Indian Television are like “find the right person” but Abhinav character is like,”be the right person”.I felt this degrading started after this custody where akshara confronts Manyujiri about Abhir’s detention.Everyone were expecting the small leap of 1 year and akshara using her Law degree to get Abhir back….in the process Abhimanyu is redeemed being with Abhir.What we got,long hair weak akshara making dumb decisions and falling into ex’s arms,and this creep lifting and shoving her into the car.(that day when I saw that scene,it literally took some time to process that shit🤮🤮).Followed by Navra Bajan for this creep and death track.I felt there was sudden shift and rush of writing. It would have been much appreciated if new person was introduced for Manyu (provided he is redeemed).But noooooo, kill the good character and throw her back to the abusive flipper family.I stopped reading updates too….I just read the comments here, because comments provide much better stories or POVs than that cringe.
@Nani
Exactly. Manyu should have moved on with another female to give room for Akshara to stay level headed. Now Akshara is worse than before.
Now the gossip sites are on about Manyu dumping Arohi for Akshara and showing pics of Arohi crying. Are the writers mental? Our girl already showed her interest in losermanyu was only for psychojiri now same Psychojiri changed her concept of the perfect family not to mention does Akshara not feel disgusted with herself for taking her sisters fiancé for the second time? Her name should be change to looseshara forget Manyu but as a sister she should be disgusted with herself. If they got rid of Akshara and brought in another FL that might be for the best
@Tsk agree with you.The story is focused on Akshara not Aarohi.Aarohi character started out as other woman ( I only saw her screaming and demanding her “right” ) pre leap.The actress herself wanted a low key character post leap (acc to her interview) There is almost nil character arc. The writers could have made her character powerful as Abhinav s but they did not bother.So whether we want it or not it’s Akshara s story with Abhimanyu.
@IrCy
Abhir sounds like Abhir. She said Abhir but you are in your fantasy right.
@A I think you don’t get what I mean, no matter how much you hated the leads , they remain the lead, by comparing Aru to Akshu is just like in…Romeo n Juliet, you like Romeo n hate Juliet, but they are both the leads no matter!
Here people saying Aru should be the lead, then this story should change the name of Akshu to Aru that’s it!
@Bu im totally glad that dumbshara name is not replaced with juliet now that you mention that😂😂😂. Actually the reason why myself and many others prefer arohi is see her character redemption. She did questionable things in her past but after the leap she became an understanding, sorted, career oriented character who focuses on her daughter. If the makers wanted us to like dumbshara so much they shouldn’t have shown her as a dumb one to begin with.
@A I think you don’t get @Tsk n @Bu, what they are saying characters are acting according to Scripts, the character Aarohi that you think should be the lead but not Akshara, coz of how the story goes, but the script was written as such, maybe you change the lead name Aarohi instead of Akshara, get it??
@A yes now i know. Actually i would have preferred arohi as the lead but as a viewer who saw from very beginning when this serial came out upto this day’s ep, i am glad she isn’t but on the other hand i feel bad for pranali because pranali is an excellent actress who also deserves a show way better where her acting range is explored more rather than shown as a dumb fictional character.
@A,
Or you mean Karisma should be the lead not Pranali?
@A i never mentioned the real name of the actresses. I am only talking about the characters they both are playing. In one way I am glad arohi isn’t the lead of this ruined show but sad for pranali because she and pranali deserves a much better show than this ruined one. Hope there would be bunch of progressed writers who would cast karishma and pranali as leads on a decent show.
Thanks @ A .I am glad I missed out completely on Naira/ Kartik bit😆
Rr no problem😂😂😂. I watched half way of season two and then stopped until the beginning of season 3
@A n @IrCy
you guys should be telling the writers to change the leads character or story, not saying Aru should be the lead instead of Abhira? Coz even the maker said this story is all about Abhira? Aru, Abhinav, Kairav, Muskaan are all characters involved in the Abhira story
@Tsk i would rather advise the makers to show the lead characters as sensible people if they want more audiences to like the leads.
About Aarohi I agree .She should now take full responsibility of Ruhi.No depending on Manjiri and Abhimanyu for ruhis physical and education needs.The birlas have made her financially dependent on them In seven years she is still a resident doctor trailing after Abhimanyu with case studies🤦♀️.Mahima and Anand don’t even bother consulting her even though she’s a share holder….and on top of that she agrees to have a ” in name” only wedding with her brother in law who she knows is in love with his ex. Seriously she’s acting so needy!! She’s become typical widowed daughter inlaw happy with crumbs 😤
@A
“@Vandana exactly only aarohi and abhinav deserved to be the leads toxicshara and toxicmanyu’s faces are unbearable.”
Now I got it, you prefer Karishma to Pranali being the lead, so it is the actresses you are comparing not the characters. “the leads toxicshara and toxicmanyu’s faces are unbearable”
Kairav not explaining Muskaan what exactly in btw him and Pallavi ,so how can Muskaan understand her husband ,obviously she differently suspect Kairavbehavior
As husband it is his responsibility to her tell what going on in his professional life otherwise ……early marriage period it’s either love/arranged it’s delicate time period u should not give a single chance to ruin u r Relationship
Not everyone like Abhinav as a companion
Most of the love marriages love happens only before marriage after that they took granted it ……. that what happening btw KandM
@Tsk you clearly did not understand what I meant. If i wanted karishma as the lead I would have used her real name not her character name. Also the reason why i said toxic shara and toxicmanyu’s faces are unbearable are because their characters are annoying but when i see them on sites like insta I don’t get annoyed. Do you get it now or do i still need to explain further? I am just telling what I feel and not trying to start a war here
@vijaya, agree Kairav cannot just expect Muskaan to be understanding when his actions speak louder than his words, any wife would suspect something is going on with him n his manager! Muskaan is so poor thing, no one is on her side or understand her now, that is why she missed Abhinav so much! Although she has her SIL/Abhinav side but she is not showing any concern for her?
Exactly @Lov Abhinav is Muskaan strong pillar in her entire life according to story, he is only person understands her and make her stabilized her emotionally too coz he knew her her long back and he is more sensible person in entire jungely janwar of yrkkh…..
Nav thought in his absence Ak mighty help and protect her sister, but this Mahaan Devi is Rather focusing her SIL , Ak more interesting abhi and manjeri family issues
Let we see how KAnd M r they rekindle their relationship like before or something?
Today also Ak rather under standing Muskaan, she pointed her actions seriously girl…..some like Nav come and show her actions and consequences,otherwise someone’s life in danger like Nav
When this Mahaan Devi come in her sense and do her own business 🤔😡😤
@A so you should blame the WRITER not judging Akshu n Abhi’s face, coz the script want them to be in that state, in order for them to show how they feel they have to make some action on their face, so then the unbearable face you saw was shown on screen! Get it! As much as you don’t want to start any dispute, me too, am only pointing out you are judging/comparing at the wrong place.
@Rai
Akshara was overlooked and ignored at the beginning????😂 you were surely one dimension on her.
Unfortunately this is not what she meant by one dimensional assessment. @vandana means, in an event, you blame only one person for it. Like “I still can’t get over Akshara choosing Arohi’s wedding day to admit her love for the groom, Abhimanyu”. You don’t see that Manyu was the one that flipped on Aru on her wedding day and threatened Akshara to confess her feelings. You cannot expect them to go ahead with the wedding after that.
You usually assess situations one dimensionally.
@Mark, @Vanadana may have been talking about plot as you suggest. I was certainly talking about character. Both accepted ways of approaching a story and applying the ‘one-dimensional’ analytical tool.
Abhi treaten Ak to confess her feelings to him in front of family members